Bin Laden's Death: Was This Murder?

[exploited]

[Professor]

A few historical precepts:

Golden Rule - "He who has the gold, makes the rules." - Who would declare this an illegal killing? Likely not any Western democracies. And, likely not any countries in which AlQ has ever operated. And, likely not any countries who have been victims of terrorist attacks. And, likely not any country with substantial economic ties to the US. That leaves NK, Venezuela, Cuba and a handful of others. They might get up and yell at the UN. But, that's as far as it'll go.

Recorded history - "The winners write the history books." - Those people likely to call this "murder" are not going to be the ones recording the accounts of this episode. The US (and allies mentioned above) will be the ones to craft the version of history that is recorded, and it will say OBL orchestrated the attacks on the US, and then he was killed by the US. That's about it.

But, to answer your question, it wasn't a political assassination. Although I don't agree with the war powers granted the President, he was authorized to kill OBL any time he wanted.

[The Dude]

In the case of OBL, I don't care what anyone wants to call it. He needed to be killed and he was.

[The Dharma Bum]

Those aren't actually the rules, Prof. The problem is too many people think they are.

[exploited]

What gave him that authorization?

The Geneva Convention is more binding than the resolution authorizing force after 9/11... according to the Constitution, anyways.

There was no act of Congress authorizing war against Pakistan. Therefore this was an intelligence operation, and consequently, a political assassination.

[The Dharma Bum]

[exploited]

[The Dude]

[uebermann]

Really? We're worried about someone killing a homicidal maniac that was in charge of other homicidal maniacs?

Look, I don't think the US should just be going out and secretly offing people, however it was no secret that the US was out to kill OBL. We declared that we were going to go after him and AQ and we did.

Not getting where the problem is here.

[eynon81]

I think it was a high risk military operation and perfectly legal. I haven't heard any evidence that he tried to surrender to American troops.